Misunderstanding the Rooftop Environment
Cause of Rooftop Greening Failure (1)
— Planning Based on the False Assumption That a Rooftop Is an Extension of the Ground
The initial perception of what kind of environment a rooftop represents has a profound influence not only on design decisions and system selection, but also on how events that occur after construction are interpreted.
Many rooftop greening failures are often discussed in terms of construction defects or maintenance issues.
However, in reality, a significant number of cases originate from misjudgments made at the planning stage regarding the rooftop environment itself.
Among these, the most typical and fundamental mistake is planning based on the assumption that a rooftop is simply an extension of ground-level conditions.
Rooftops Are Fundamentally Different from Ground-Level Environments
Because rooftops are located at the top of buildings, they are subject to conditions that differ essentially from those on the ground:
・Few elements to block wind
・Direct exposure to solar radiation
・Rapid and extreme temperature fluctuations
・A tendency toward dry atmospheric conditions
・Severely limited available soil volume
・Environments that are not continuously accessed by people
Despite these differences, planning decisions are sometimes made based on reasoning such as:
・“This method has proven effective at ground level.”
・“There were no issues in parks or planting strips.”
As a result, ground-based greening concepts are directly transferred to rooftop applications.
At that moment, rooftop greening is already being placed on an inherently unstable foundation.
The Impact of Wind and Limited Soil Volume on Rooftops
On rooftops, the drying effects of wind exert a far greater influence on both plants and soil than is often anticipated.
Even when air temperatures are similar, increased evapotranspiration caused by wind leads to moisture being lost at a much faster rate than expected.
In addition, rooftops frequently cannot accommodate sufficiently deep soil layers.
Unlike ground-level planting, there is little margin for error where:
“Minor problems can be absorbed by soil volume.”
This margin simply does not exist on rooftops.
As a result, even small deviations in judgment at the design stage can surface several years later as poor plant performance or localized dieback.
Rooftop Greening Must Be Designed for Rooftop Conditions
Rooftop greening should not be evaluated based on whether it has succeeded at ground level.
Instead, it must be designed on the premise of whether it can adapt to the rooftop environment itself.
When this fundamental premise is mistaken, no amount of adjustment to systems, plant selection, or maintenance practices can reliably ensure long-term stability.
Rooftop greening is not an extension of ground-level greening.
It must be treated as an independent design discipline, specifically tailored to the unique conditions of rooftop environments.
Back to Site Top▶
The Structure Behind Sound Judgment▶
Structures That Lead to Failure▶
